For over a decade, we as one world have worked hard to put together a gathering with everything we want to know. This amazingly large gathering, for all Americans, is the information highway. The internet has been America’s way for many years and has been working out well. There is no reason for change and there should be no change. So far, there have not been large problems due to the internet that cannot be controlled and the government should avoid making one now. Censorship is just another excuse for people who want to be dictators to have an option, and when done under the name of “National Security” it cannot be justified. America is not, and should not, be shown as a dictating- hungry country. Censorship will be doing this. Nothing good really comes from this widespread controversy. Censorship of the internet will only lead to a lack of open knowledge, denial of citizen rights and disruption of privacy which can be easily proved.
A major disadvantage due to censorship would be no more free information available to the public. However, if a site was able to stay up and have the information available, it would have to pass through many checks; and if it was allowed there would be many regulations. All posters would have to agree with contracts for free use of information and there would be regulations “including legal regulations on content, technical filtering and blocking websites, self- censorship, the vibrancy/ diversity of online news media, and the use of ICTs for civic mobilization.” (Kelly) Even though that seems like a lot, it all means that no site would be able to have posts that mentioned any other site, person, video, or any form of addressing available to the public; and that is much bigger than it sounds. “From censorship of the Internet, sites which people use everyday will be banned. Free info sites that are open to the public will be cut off from all access. If the Internet is censored, due to copyrights, information sites that have no rule against copyrighting will be banned.” (Ockerbloom) All sites that others can post on will be deleted. Wiki, being a public posting site, would delete due to copyright infringements. Yahoo and public response websites, such as Ask, would be blocked. If the internetwas censored, every word posted would have to go through tests to allow posting. “Some sensitive phrases could not be posted at all.” (MacKinnon) Even though most rude comments and abuses would be filtered, there no longer would be quick responses. Most people depend on these quick responses for questions and censorship takes this away from the public. Over 50 percent of Americans use Yahoo, Wiki, and similar sites for answers. Not only would response site be blocked, online dictionaries would be censored, too. Online dictionaries are sometimes public and can have the public add comments and posts to them. For this reason, they would result in blockage since according to law all resources MUST be stated. Censoring would cause “infractual and economic barriers to access, legal ownership control over internet service providers (ISPs), and independence of regulatory bodies.” (Kelly) Almost all educational things be blocked, but entertainment too would be censored.
The internet is public; the people made it for the people. Citizen rights are denied with censorship by the government. “We need to understand conflicts of intellectual freedom, not as something negative or practiced by those less enlightened than ourselves, but as a process in which we are all participants playing various roles based on age, family background, societal position, religious beliefs, and profession.” (Vandergrift) The people worked to make the internet and now should be allowed to use it as they wish. Not only does censorship deny country- wide public uses but also private uses.
The government is harming the people by taking away what is theirs. Censorship partly denies “freedom of speech.” If the citizens are no longer to talk about what they want for themselves, nobody will be able to. Social sites and broadcasts sites are often used to send messages out to everyone and music in background or even singing of copyrighted songs can have posts deleted. These sites allow people to raise public awareness about problems. People, who depend on these sites, really would prefer a world without censoring. In reality, not many people want censorship at all. Only 2 in 30 people in the United States agree with censorship. Not only that, only 16 out of 100 senators were for censorship during voting. In addition, the biggest effect, the President even disagrees with censoring.
Mr. President disagreeing is a lawful thing since censorship is even against the Constitution. The first amendment clearly states that there should be no law prohibiting free exercise.
This breaks the U.S.’s own law that has worked for everyone for the last few decades. If the people who made it break the Constitution, it would result in major news spreading quickly. There could be an arousal of possible protests or problems in the future. China is a perfect example of what could happen; China had protests after it was censored. In addition, Australia had protests to after censorship of the internet. The people of this nation rarely stand for abrupt changes. There may be results in unfortunate relations with the government. If censorship is allowed, there may be outbreaks and protests across the nation. United States is also filled with opinionated people and a protest in in the U.S. in much more likely to occur versus than any other country. Honestly, this could lead to a slight rebellion just as it did in previous countries. Even though censorship may sound all bad, there are a few legitimate reasons.
The idea of censoring the internet first came up when PIPA (Protect IP Act) and SOPA (The Stop Online Piracy Act), two bills, were first passed to the government. While the Obama administration has come out against SOPA and has put SOPA to a halt for time being, the very similar PIPA bill is still alive and well. Both PIPA and SOPA wanted to have the internet censored for one of two main reasons: to avoid identity theft/ avoid intrusion of privacy. However, PIPA’s plan was tried and failed miserably. Even though SOPA no longer positions a hurdle, PIPA still is a threat to the nation’s freedom. PIPA not only wants the government to censor but the entertainment industry to have power also.
The reason that blocking a domain name is not effective is because any blocked site can still be accessed via its numeric IP address. For example, if “lifehacker.com” became blocked, you could still find it by visiting a number-based address. In fact, before the bills were even supposed to come to a vote, tools were created to automatically route domain names to their IP addresses to render completely this measure of SOPA and PIPA useless. The domain name reason has been used to attempt censoring of the internet previously many times, but to our luck, it never was successful. However, there is another reason that both PIPA and SOPA hold.
Google, Facebook, Twitter, Zynga, eBay, Mozilla, Yahoo, AOL, and LinkedIn released a letter to Congress, saying that if the bills passed, they would have to monitor constantly their content for copyright infringement, before it goes up, or face litigation. Some of these groups even “censored” their logos as a protest against the bills. Even though all this effort was put in, there still were Congress members that could not realize what the outcome of censoring could be. Many sites would shut down because whatever is posted becomes is the responsibility of the site it is posted on. Continues monitoring of every public site would take much time up and could possibly result in sites shutting down. Some sites, that are unable to monitor properly, would be sued and shut down. Links on sites could cause suing or law cases. Links and site names would be taken off, messing with the basic layout of the internet causing weakened privacy for anyone on the web.
These people who want censorship do not see how it could affect the world. “The purpose of these bills are to make it harder for sites — especially those located outside the United States — to sell or distribute pirated copyrighted material such as movies and music as well as physical goods such as counterfeit purses and watches.”(Magid) This would lead to a slightly better economy, but if anyone looks back at the very similar past, drug dealings weren’t stopped, illegal immigrants weren’t stopped, oversea thefts weren’t stopped and chances are counterfeit items sold to other nations will not be stopped either. The bill, if passed, would require every site to refrain links to any other sites that are “dedicated to the theft of U.S. property.” It would also prevent companies from adding advertisements or links on the sites and block payment companies like Visa, MasterCard and PayPal from transmitting funds to the site. The problem with this is that the entire site would be affected, not just that portion that is promoting the distribution of illegal material or merchandise. The bill would also cut off funding by prohibiting payment services from cooperating with infringing sites. Many things would be put to play with censoring “including (complete) surveillance, (intrusion of) privacy, and repercussions for online activity such as imprisonment, extra legal harassment, or cyber attacks.” (Kelly) “Just because law states that good should happen, does not mean good will happen. Over half of the internet will be filtered and erased.”(Walske) “The Internet is a crucial medium through which people can express themselves and share ideas and has become an increasingly important tool through which democracy and human rights activists and all Americans mobilize and advocate for political, social, and economic reform.” All people need something for communication and the internet is what this communication is.
Aley, Micheal. "Do not censor the Internet." Student Life. N.p., 17 Jan. 2012. Web. 11 Mar. 2012. <www.studlife.com/forum/staff-editorials/2011/11/17/don%e2%80%99t-censor-the-internet/#comment-22709>.
Atkins, Robert, and Svetlana Mintcheva. "Bad To Worse: Outcomes." Censoring culture: contemporary threats to free expression. New York: New Press, 2006. 75. Print.
Gilmore, John. Interview by James Dean. Personal interview. 3 Aug. 2000.
Hughes, Chris. Interview by Zoe Fox. Personal interview. 19 Aug. 2011.
Herumin, Wendy. "Conflictions." Censorship on the Internet: from filters to freedom of speech. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow Publishers, 2004. 73. Print.
Kelly, Sanja. "Freedom on the Net." Freedom House. New York: Freedom House, 2000. 12. Print. including (complete) surveillance
Kelly, Sanja. "Freedom on the Net." Freedom House. New York: Freedom House, 2000. 13. Print. including legal regulations on content
Kelly, Sanja. "Freedom on the Net." Freedom House. New York: Freedom House, 2000. 14. Print. infractual and economic barriers
Kolbert, Kathryn, and Zak Mettger. "But There Is More." Censoring the Web. New York: New Press, 2001. 34. Print.
MacKinnon, Rebecca. "Public Posting." "Race to the bottom": corporate complicity in Internet censorship.. New York: Human Rights Watch, 2006. 11. Print. Some sensitive phrases could
Marzilli, Alan. "It is True." Policing the Internet. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 2005. 93. Print.
Morozov, Evgeny. "Internet Freedoms and Their Consequences." The net delusion: the dark side of Internet freedom. New York, NY: PublicAffairs, 2011. 253. Print.
Nunziato, Dawn C.. "When Private Becomes Public." Virtual freedom: net neutrality and free speech in the Internet age. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford Law Books, 2009. 92. Print.
Nunziato, Dawn C.. "A Place To Speak Your Mind." Virtual freedom: net neutrality and free speech in the Internet age. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford Law Books, 2009. 75. Print.
Ockerbloom, John. "Banned." The online books page. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Library., 2008. 26. Print. From censorship of the Internet
Pillai, Prabhakar. "Pros and Cons of Censorship." Buzzle Web Portal: Intelligent Life on the Web. N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Mar. 2012. <http://www.buzzle.com/articles/pros-and-cons-of-censorship.html>.
Vandergrift, Kay E.. "Censorship, the Internet, Intellectual Freedom, and Youth." Time Magazine 5 May 1997: 15. Print. We need to understand conflicts
Walker, Christopher. "Internet Freedom." Freedom House. New York: Freedom House, 2000. 17. Print.
Walske, Christine. "Possible Outcomes." Internet censorship: protecting citizens or trampling freedom?. Minneapolis: Twenty-First Century Books, 2010. 94. Print. Just because law
Zuchora- Walske, Christine. "What We Say." Internet censorship protecting citizens or trampling freedom?. Minneapolis: Twenty-First Century Books, 2010. 9. Print.


2 comments:
FARIHA!
Whhhatttt??? I got an 105% though!
Post a Comment